What the manufacturers of Amalgam say...
Although Dental Associations in many countries are
still claiming that Amalgam is safe, even the manufacturers of amalgam fillings are
starting to warn dentists of side effects.
Where amalgam should not be used
Dental safety protocol
& procedures for amalgam removal
Fallacies
Amalgam
should not be used:
Caulk Company, manufacturers of Dispersalloy state that
their product should NOT be used:
* In contact with dissimilar metal
restorations
* In patients with severe renal deficiencies
* In patients with known allergies to amalgam
* In retrograde or endodontic filling
* As a filling material for cast crown
* In children 6 and under
* In expectant mothers
Ivoclar/Vivadent go further in
advising against
* Nursing mothers as well as expectant
mothers
* All patients with reduced kidney
function
Return to top of page
Dental safety protocol for removal of amalgam
Appropriate equipment must be installed and strict
procedures must be observed in order to remove amalgams safely. Our equipment and
procedures ensure safety for the patient and for the dental team while extracting the
material and for the environment by handling and disposing of the material appropriately.
Procedure includes:
Surgery Air filtration
Meter readings taken
Rubber dam put in place although this can be uncomfortable it makes a big
difference to your mercury exposure.
High volume water and suction
Air extraction equipment specifically designed for the purpose by a ventilation
engineer and unique to our facilities
Disposal method
Return to top
of page
Fallacies
There are many claims made by the Dental
Associations in America, Canada and Australia along with other countries claiming that
dental amalgam is safe to use as a filling material. There is a lot of published
experimental evidence that many of these statements are false and misleading.
Claim |
Contrary
Evidence |
Mercury
is not poisonous when used in dental amalgam as it is combined with other metals such as
silver, tin and copper. It reacts with them to form a biologically inactive substance |
Mercury
is not neutralised by the other products. Because mercury is diluted by the other
substances the vapour pressure is reduced, however mercury vapour is still released. |
When
you eat or chew vigorously very small quantities of mercury vapour are absorbed by the
body, but no evidence exists that associate this minute amount of mercury vapour with any
toxic effect. |
Although
there is no threshold level of mercury exposure that can be considered totally harmless,
the US Environmental Protection Agencys has defined a maximum allowable
concentration for air quality. Measurements have shown that intra-oral levels of mercury
vapour are between thirty and 100 hundred times higher than that level. Tests on pregnant
sheep have shown that mercury has passed into both the sheep and foetal tissues
including organs, glands and brain. After 33 days, most foetal tissues had higher levels
of mercury than the maternal tissues. |
A
major source of mercury exposure is from fish in the diet. |
It has
been scientifically concluded that mercury/silver fillings constitute the largest source
of inorganic mercury exposure to the general population and this exposure exceeds organic
mercury exposure from fish. |
The
profession has been using amalgam for more than 150 years. Some of the newer materials
used have only been around for a decade or less, so we dont have a long-standing
history of safety with then that we have with amalgam. |
This
statement by the American Dental Association gives the distinct impression that dental
amalgam has the ADA "seal of approval." In fact the ADA has maintained that
mixed dental amalgam is a reaction product manufactured by the individual dentist and
therefore cannot be certified and it is the responsibility of the individual dentist to
determine the efficacy of the materials and their appropriateness for each patient. |
ADA
states that the strongest and most convincing support we have for the safety of dental
amalgam is the fact that each year more than 100 million amalgam fillings are placed in
the United States. |
This
is approximately 72 tons of mercury per year. Historically, numerous products such as
asbestos, lead and DDT were thought to be safe and scientific concerns were discounted by
the industry responsible. Each of these products demonstrated pathology after a latency
period of chronic low dose exposure as does mercury. Moreover, the pathology from mercury
is of a medical nature and would not be apparent to most dentists. Most Physicians would
not be aware of the possibility that mercury from fillings might have induced the
pathology. |
Since
1984 the ADA has claimed that the incidence of hypersensitivity to mercury is less that 1% |
Scientific
literature has reported skin allergy to mercury occurs in approximately 5% of the general
population. Between 2% and 35% of people with amalgam fillings test hypersensitive to
mercury. The incidence of this adverse reaction gradually increases with time and the
onset may be delayed five or more years. |
Return
to top of page
More information can
be obtained from organisations such as ASOMAT - the Australasian Society of
Oral Medicine and Toxicology. It is a non-profit professional organisation
of dentists and doctors with associate membership open to all other
interested people. Information is available from their web site at www.asomat.com.
Another organisation
is the International Academy of Oral Medicine and Toxicology, located in
Calgary in Canada.
Affinity Labelling
Technologies is an organisation which has a web site designed as an
educational resource for researchers and persons working in the health care
field including dentistry. Their web site is www.altcorp.com
Return to
top of page
Disclaimer of
liability: Eric Davis Dental web sit is a site designed to inform patients about
alternatives to traditional dental procedures and materials. The opinions presented
at Eric Davis Dental are controversial and many are disputed by other dental
practitioners. Dr Davis expressly disclaims all liability arising out of the
improper use of the information provided. Please consult your treating physician or
other dental professional regarding these important health issues.
|